Recently I considered leaving ConvertKit to move my email marketing over to ActiveCampaign. So I’m going to share my opinion of the pros & cons of ActiveCampaign vs ConvertKit.
When it comes to my business philosophy, I’m a bit of a tool minimalist. Remember how much I love Dubsado, because it took the place of Gmail & Bidsketch & FreeAgent & HelloSign, rolling it all up into one simplified workflow?
Well when I heard that ActiveCampaign has a fully-formed client CRM built into its platform (currently I use and love Nimble) and it had all the functionality of ConvertKit, I had to check it out. Especially since at first glance, it looked like it would cost me LESS to use ActiveCampaign than ConvertKit + Nimble! #frugalentrepreneur
So without further ado, here is my overview of the pros and cons of each, and why I made my email marketing software decision.
Pros of ActiveCampaign
- The rumor is true: the ActiveCampaign CRM is pretty robust. I had a chance to check it out during the free trial, and I was impressed by the amount of data that I could import and track. The CRM also includes client purchase histories within the data, and I could use it to segment my email list. (ConvertKit is just rolling out this feature, but ActiveCampaign has it on lock.)
- ActiveCampaign could easily replace not just ConvertKit, but also, my email inbox. The CRM could be the place where I do ALLLLLL my emailing, not just my broadcasts. (Which is cool, but also a little scary for me … what if I intended an email for just one friend and ended up sending it to my whole list? Eeek!)
- The automations are powerful. Like, I could set up a branched logic automation that could easily take a subscriber through multiple buying scenarios, with a lot of “if they buy, do this,” “if they open but don’t buy, do this,” “if they don’t open, do this.” It’s really freaking cool, and I felt like I could fall down a rabbit hole very easily with all the ways I could use those systems.
- The versatility of their opt-in boxes is extensive. They can be added as a top-bar, in-line, mobile popups, and/or at the end of every blog post. (Unfortunately, you have to add the code for each of those separately — their WordPress plug-in is pretty lame.)
- It can focus on different tasks to help grow your business. When I opened up the workflows, the goals it was working towards were ambitious: increase review, increase traffic, automate sales funnel, boost customer satisfaction, manage contacts.
Cons of ActiveCampaign
- Notice the words I used to describe it: robust, powerful, ambitious. Those are all positive traits … but there’s a dark side to being able to do everything: the software is overwhelming.
Guys, I’m a self-proclaimed tech geek, and I adore a good marketing funnel. But I looked at all the possibilities and was totally in over my head — both strategically and functionally.
- It is NOT intuitive. I’m sure I could have figured it out eventually, but gosh, there are a lot of moving parts. I’m used to ConvertKit, where the plugin puts a default form on my each post (unless I turn it off), the autoresponder has an attachment that goes with the opt-in confirmation, and that easily flows into a sequence (which can all be written in one window).
But with ActiveCampaign, I would have had to embed each form by hand into each post, and then specify an automation that would trigger a workflow, and each email in the workflow needs to be opened separately.
- It looks like it’s going to be cheaper than ConvertKit … but the “Lite” version (which is $17/mo for <1000 subscribers, compared to ConvertKit’s $29/mo for the same number) is really lacking. It doesn’t include the CRM, everything is branded, you can’t include a hello bar or modal lead captures … in order to really utilize the power of ActiveCampaign, you’re looking at $49/mo, at least. (Which is what I’m paying for ConvertKit + Nimble, so turns out it wouldn’t save me any money after all.)
Pros of ConvertKit
- I’ve already written about all the reasons I love ConvertKit when I made the jump from MailChimp. All those pros still hold:
- It has a 14-day free trial, if you want to check it out. (Note: That’s an affiliate link; consider that a hint at which of these e-mail softwares I ended up choosing!)
- It’s really easy to use, and intuitive to navigate. I feel like I was up-to-speed on how to run ConvertKit within a few hours of poking around.
- It’s focused on email marketing and doing it well, without trying to bite off too much functionality.
- The WordPress plug-in makes things SO EASY.
- Email courses are easy to create and modify, with a drag and drop interface that lets you rearrange emails in seconds. Automation rules are equally simple, with no development experience required to create powerful automated email campaigns.
- ConvertKit sends clean, readable emails that look great on desktop and on mobile.
Cons of ConvertKit
- Because it doesn’t have the CRM functionality, segmentation & customization isn’t nearly as robust.
- The landing page builder kind of sucks. Like I’m a designer & I know CSS, and I still can’t get the damn things to look pretty. (I just embed a form on a page on my site.)
On paper, it seemed like a good idea … but now that I’ve tried out ActiveCampaign vs. ConvertKit, I’ve decided to stick with ConvertKit for my service-based business. Let me share why.
ActiveCampaign considers itself “a powerful all-in-one solution for marketers and sales teams.” It goes beyond e-mail marketing to include every part of moving a prospect to a customer, including customer segments and lead scoring.
But for me? I’m a solopreneur with a small team: ConvertKit is made for businesses like mine — it brands itself as being made for bloggers and content marketers, and that’s exactly what I am. ConvertKit gives me an easy way to connect with the people on my e-mail list, and the opportunity to set up automated sequences to onboard new subscribers … without needing to bring in a specialist to set up complex, linking code in my site. It’s really easy to write email sequences all in one window, and to update them quickly & easily.
So if you have a robust sales team AND want to do complex email marketing sales funnels, ActiveCampaign is probably for you.
If you’re a solopreneur or running a small team and want a system that just works out of the box? ConvertKit’s probably a better fit.
Want to try before you buy? Get a 14-day free trial to ConvertKit.
Your SEO Starter Kit
Get your FREE guide full of fun tips (and flow charts, mad libs, and references to The Office) to get found on Google ... without needing a degree in nerdspeak.